Comparison SKY VIEW™ vs “The Competition”

The Clear Top Showdown: Which One Really Delivers?
Not all Jeep clear tops are built the same. On paper, they might look similar, transparent material, removable panels, a supposed “OEM-style” fit, but when you get hands-on, the differences become obvious.

We took a closer look at two of the most talked-about options on the market: one that’s become a go-to among Jeep enthusiasts, and another that’s been quietly gaining attention for its engineering, materials, and out-of-the-box performance.

What we found might surprise you.

From real-world fitment and insulation to road noise, clarity, and weather resistance, this head-to-head breakdown goes beyond surface-level specs. If you’re considering a clear top upgrade, this is the comparison you’ll want to see before making a decision.

Quick breakdown

Features	SKY VIEW™	Other Clear lids “Competitors”
Polycarbonate Type	✅ Makrolon® Tuffak	❌ Generic poly-carbonate
Weather Seal	✅ Automotive-grade precision seal	❌ Generic and low quality hardware
Fitment	✅ True OEM direct-fit, arrives fully assembled	❌ May require rubber trimming (Extra fitting steps according to customer reports)
Fast Install/Removal	✅ Minutes, no tools	✅ Minutes, no tools
Wind/Water Resistant	✅ Same high-sealing standard as OEM	❌ Prone to water leaks (According to several reviews)
Extreme Temp Durable	✅ -200°F to +150°F (3rd-party verified)	❌ Unverified
All-Season Insulation	✅ I35 Dark Gray Tint & UV-stabilized	❌ Unverified
Storage Bag	✅ Free / Included	❌ Sold separately
Made in USA	✅ Des Moines, IA. USA	✅ USA
Warranty	✅ 3-Year Limited	✅ 3-Year Limited

SKY VIEW™ vs ClearLidz video

Watch a head-to-head with the so-called “competition”, from clarity and design to fit and finish, see exactly why Putco doesn’t just match the standard… we set it. If you’re still settling for less, this might change your mind.