Not all clear tops are built the same. On paper, they might look similar—transparent material, removable panels, a supposed “OEM-style” fit—but when you get hands-on, the differences become apparent.
We took a closer look at two of the most talked-about options on the market: ClearLidz and Putco’s Element Sky View. One has become a go-to among Jeep enthusiasts for its sleek profile and flush hardware. The other is gaining momentum thanks to thoughtful engineering, integrated components, and standout build quality straight out of the box.
What we found might surprise you. Yes, both tops offer panoramic views and UV-blocking tint. But real-world differences in installation, fit, hardware design, road noise, clarity, and weather resistance tell two very different stories. This isn’t just about which top looks cooler or costs less—it’s about how it actually performs on your vehicle, day in and day out.
If you’re considering a clear top upgrade, this is the comparison you’ll want to read before making your decision. Because once it’s installed, you’ll want more than just a better view—you’ll want confidence in every mile.
Sky View™ vs The Competition
Watch a head-to-head comparison with the competition, from clarity and design to fit and finish, and see precisely why Putco doesn’t just match the standard – we set it. If you’re still settling for less, this might change your mind.
Exactly what i was looking for, good info.
I sold my ClearLid on Facebook Marketplace and picked up a Sky View about two months ago—zero regrets. Honestly, I wish I had seen this video a year ago. It would’ve saved me the hassle. Also, good luck getting any kind of support from ClearLids… it was a nightmare. Never going back